• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Alison Law
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
    • Actions Against Public Bodies
    • Civil & Commercial Litigation
    • Commercial Leases
    • Criminal Law
    • Employment Law
    • Family Law
    • Intellectual Property
    • International Disputes
    • Immigration
    • Landlord & Tenant Services
    • Legal Aid
    • Personal Injury & Medical Negligence
    • Taxation
  • Fees & Funding
  • For Clients
    • Accreditations – Working towards Excellence
    • Complete Instruction Sheet
    • Pay Your Invoice Here
    • Your Secure Documents
    • Our Prices
    • Make an Enquiry Here
    • Our Equality and Diversity Responses
  • Careers
  • News
  • Service Portal
  • Contact Us

May 23, 2019 By Alison Law Solicitors

Court of Appeal clarifies scope of lawful act duress

Where consent to a contract is induced by duress, the contract is voidable by the aggrieved party. One form of duress is “economic” duress. A party seeking to prove economic duress must show the existence of illegitimate pressure applied by the defendant without which it would not have entered the contract. The illegitimate pressure will typically take the form of a crime or tort or breach of contract but there have also been cases where unethical but lawful acts have been held to constitute economic duress.

The Court of Appeal (David Richards LJ giving the lead judgment, Moylan and Asplin LJJ concurring) has ruled that a travel agent was not entitled to avoid a contract with an airline for economic duress.

The airline was the sole operator of direct flights between the UK and Pakistan, and the travel agent’s business largely depended on its ability to sell tickets for its flights pursuant to an agency agreement. By 2012, many of the airline’s agents had begun litigation against it to recover allegedly unpaid commission. The airline gave notice terminating all its existing agency agreements and reduced its agents’ ticket allocations. It offered them new contracts, but only on terms that they waive any claim for commission accrued under their previous agency agreements. The travel agent accepted the new contract but thereafter brought proceedings in which it argued that the contract containing the waiver had resulted from economic duress. It succeeded at first instance. The airline appealed.

Following an extensive review of the authorities, David Richards LJ held that a claim for lawful act duress would not succeed in a commercial context where a party was making lawful acts or threats in support of a demand that it genuinely and reasonably believed it was entitled to make. He then considered the position where that belief, though genuine, was unreasonable and concluded that the court should not extend lawful act duress to cover this scenario either. He emphasised that the common law has always rejected the use, or abuse, of a monopoly position as grounds for setting aside a contract. Accordingly, the appeal succeeded.

Appellate courts rarely have the opportunity to consider the law on economic duress. This judgment helps clarify a grey area of contract law.

Case: Times Travel (UK) Limited v Pakistan International Airlines Corporation [2019] EWCA Civ 828 (14 May 2019) (David Richards, Moylan and Asplin LJJ).

credit to Practical Law 

 

Filed Under: Civil Litigation Cases, News

Previous Post: « Court of Appeal upholds defendant’s Part 36 offer including unpleaded counterclaim and interest post-expiry of Relevant Period
Next Post: Housing Disrepair – How we can help you? »

Our Offices

  • Alison Law Solicitors
  • Sheffield (Head Office)
  • 437-441 London Road,
  • Sheffield,
  • S2 4HJ
  • 0114 258 6966
  • info@alison-law.co.uk
  • Fax: 0114 258 3707

For Directions Click Here

  • Alison Law Solicitors
  • Manchester (Branch Office)
  • 2 Wilmslow Road,
  • Manchester,
  • M14 5TP
  • 0161 674 0166
  • mcr@alison-law.co.uk
  • Fax: 0161 694 6916

For Directions Click Here

  • Alison Law Solicitors
  • Bradford (Branch Office)
  • Unit 10e Campus Road,
  • Bradford,
  • BD7 1HR
  • 01274 945 970
  • bradford@alison-law.co.uk
  • Fax: 0114 258 3707

For Directions Click Here

  • Alison Law Solicitors
  • Oldham (Branch Office)
  • 33 Featherstall Road North
  • First Floor
  • OL9 6QA
  • 0161 549 0666
  • oldham@alison-law.co.uk
  • Fax: 0161 694 6916

For Directions Click Here

  • Alison Law Solicitors
  • Blackburn (By Appointments Only)
  • Suite 7, Kings Court, 33 King Street
  • Blackburn,
  • BB2 2DH
  • 01254 495 466
  • blackburn@alison-law.co.uk
  • Fax: 0161 694 6916

For Directions Click Here

Footer

Our Firm

We provide the highest standards of legal support, assistance and representation

Our Services

  • Actions Against Public Bodies
  • Accreditations – Working towards Excellence
  • Civil & Commercial Litigation
  • Criminal Law
  • Family Department
  • Intellectual Property
  • International Disputes
  • Immigration
  • Landlord & Tenant Services
  • Legal Aid
  • Personal Injury
  • Taxation

Find More

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Fees & Funding
  • News
  • Privacy Policy
  • Complaint Policy
  • Modern Slavery Act Statement
  • Website Legal Notice

Connect With Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Alison Law Solicitors

 

COPYRIGHT © 2021 – ALISON LAW SOLICITORS IS A TRADING NAME OF ALISON LAW SOLICITORS LLP, A LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP REGISTERED IN ENGLAND AND WALES UNDER NUMBER OC378803. REGISTERED OFFICE: ALISON HOUSE, 437-441 LONDON ROAD, SHEFFIELD, S2 4HJ. AUTHORISED AND REGULATED BY THE SOLICITORS REGULATION AUTHORITY OF ENGLAND AND WALES WITH REGISTERED NUMBER 573279 AND 641704. LIST OF MEMBERS AND NON MEMBERS WHO ARE ‘PARTNERS’ ARE AVAILABLE AT THE REGISTERED OFFICE. ALISON LAW SOLICITOR’S LOGO IS A REGISTERED TRADEMARK. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. VAT NUMBER 157 2011 39. WE DO NOT ACCEPT SERVICE OF DOCUMENTS BY EMAIL OR FAX. CREATED BY Zaliet Logo Zaliet Law Firm Websites | Hosted by LEAP LEGAL SOFTWARE · LOGIN

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Necessary
Always Enabled